| Rank | Team | Baserunning Index | Record |
| 1. | Washington Nationals, 2010 | -.0111 | 57-105 |
| 2. | Washington Nationals, 2008 | .0256 | 48-114 |
| 3. | San Francisco Giants, 1958 | .0298 | 70-84 |
| 4. | Detroit Tigers, 1952 | .0375 | 63-91 |
| 5. | St. Louis Browns, 1953 | .0394 | 56-98 |
| 6. | Toronto Blue Jays, 2010 | .0405 | 53-109 |
| 7. | Detroit Tigers, 1953 | .0425 | 64-90 |
| 8. | Washington Senators, 1959 | .0545 | 57-97 |
| 9. | Toronto Blue Jays, 2011 | .0581 | 67-95 |
| 10. | Pittsburgh Pirates, 1953 | .0588 | 63-91 |
| 11. | Baltimore Orioles, 1958 | .0619 | 75-79 |
| 12. | St. Louis Cardinals, 2011 | .0633 | 74-88 |
| 13. | Boston Braves, 1952 | .0703 | 63-91 |
| 14. | Boston Red Sox, 1954 | .0723 | 64-90 |
| 15. | Kansas City A's, 1957 | .0746 | 59-95 |
| 16. | Philadelphia A's, 1945 | .0779 | 57-97 |
| 17. | St. Louis Cardinals, 1958 | .0815 | 70-84 |
| 18. | Washington Senators, 1956 | .0862 | 48-106 |
| 19. | St. Louis Cardinals, 1999 | .0876 | 76-86 |
| 20. | Detroit Tigers, 2008 | .0883 | 76-86 |
| 21. | Detroit Tigers, 2006 | .0891 | 81-81 |
| 22. | Milwaukee Braves, 1953 | .0903 | 92-62 |
| 23. | Washington Senators, 1958 | .0961 | 42-112 |
| 24. | Washington Senators, 1957 | .0966 | 55-99 |
| 25. | Texas Rangers, 1996 | .0976 | 89-73 |
| 26. | Washington Nationals, 2009 | .0983 | 72-90 |
| 27. | Chicago Cubs, 1953 | .0988 | 60-94 |
| 28. | Washington Senators, 1970 | .0997 | 72-90 |
| 29. | Seattle Mariners, 1979 | .1014 | 68-94 |
| 30. | Washington Senators, 1949 | .1021 | 61-93 |
| 31. | St. Louis Cardinals, 2013 | .1024 | 86-76 |
| 32. | Chicago Cubs, 1963 | .1032 | 96-66 |
| 33. | Minnesota Twins, 1963 | .1033 | 81-81 |
| 34. | Oakland A's, 1993 | .1038 | 60-102 |
| 35. | Detroit Tigers, 1957 | .1049 | 88-66 |
| 36. | Chicago Cubs, 1978 | .1064 | 54-108 |
| 37. | Pittsburgh Pirates, 1952 | .1067 | 64-90 |
| 38. | Philadelphia A's, 1946 | .1102 | 48-106 |
| 39. | Detroit Tigers, 1951 | .1120 | 58-96 |
| 40. | Texas Rangers, 2008 | .1134 | 55-107 |
| 41. | St. Louis Browns, 1952 | .1144 | 64-90 |
| 42. | Boston Red Sox, 1956 | .1156 | 81-73 |
| 43. | Philadelphia A's, 1951 | .1175 | 84-70 |
| 44. | St. Louis Browns, 1951 | .1184 | 64-90 |
| 45. | Philadelphia A's, 1949 | .1189 | 84-70 |
| 46. | Oakland A's, 1998 | .1196 | 65-97 |
| 47. | Texas Rangers, 2004 | .1220 | 74-88 |
| 48. | Pittsburgh Pirates, 1954 | .1233 | 55-99 |
| 49. | New York Giants, 1937 | .1237 | 76-78 |
| 50. | Baltimore Orioles, 2011 | .1241 | 80-82 |