Quick Index: Teams | Leagues | Managers | Postseason
You Are Here > smileyleague.org > Posted Messages

Posted Messages                

Go to message #    

# Date Sender Subject
29861 Feb 13, 2014   Steve Bivens   If you care...Robert Lee Johnson
29862 Feb 13, 2014   James Pardee   Re: [SmileyList] If you care...Robert Lee Johnson
29863 Feb 13, 2014   Mark Simons   Brewers Pick
29864 Feb 13, 2014   Alan Boodman   A's are up
29865 Feb 13, 2014   Andrew Kennedy   Re: [SmileyList] A's select Bobby Ayala
29866 Feb 13, 2014   Alan Boodman   Royals are up
29867 Feb 13, 2014   James Pardee   Royals select M Freeman , Red Sox up
29868 Feb 13, 2014   Alan Boodman   Red Sox are up
29869 Feb 13, 2014   Michael Tomeo   Sox pick.. Mets up
29870 Feb 13, 2014   Alan Boodman   Mets are up
29871 Feb 14, 2014   Jonathan Fellows   Mets pick Pete Schourek. Cubs are up
29872 Feb 14, 2014   Alan Boodman   Cubs are up
29873 Feb 14, 2014   Tom Edwards   Re: [SmileyList] Cubs are up
29874 Feb 14, 2014   Michael Rescigno   Re: [SmileyList] Cardinals select
29875 Feb 14, 2014   Michael Tomeo   Tigers up
29876 Feb 14, 2014   Mike Mashanic   Re: [SmileyList] Tigers & Pirates select Blue Jays up
29877 Feb 14, 2014   Mike Mashanic   Re: [SmileyList] Tigers & Pirates select Blue Jays up
29878 Feb 14, 2014   Mike Mashanic   Re: [SmileyList] Tigers & Pirates select Blue Jays up
29879 Feb 14, 2014   Alan Boodman   Blue Jays pick; Yankees are up
29880 Feb 15, 2014   Robert Rescigno   RE: [SmileyList] Yankees pick Mariners up
29881 Feb 15, 2014   Jeff Tripodi   Re: [SmileyList] Yankees pick Mariners up
29882 Feb 15, 2014   Alan Boodman   White Sox are up
29883 Feb 15, 2014   Ben Lea   The old get older; White Sox pick ...
29884 Feb 15, 2014   Thomas Treece   Florida selects
29885 Feb 15, 2014   Thomas Treece   Re: [SmileyList] Florida selects
29886 Feb 15, 2014   Andrew Kennedy   Re: [SmileyList] A's select Mike Huff
29887 Feb 15, 2014   Alan Boodman   Padres are up
29888 Feb 15, 2014   Michael Tomeo   Re: [SmileyList] Padres are up
29889 Feb 15, 2014   Alan Boodman   Brewers are up
29890 Feb 15, 2014   Alan Boodman   files updated
29891 Feb 15, 2014   Mark Simons   Re: [SmileyList] Brewers are up
29892 Feb 16, 2014   Alan Boodman   Cubs are up
29893 Feb 16, 2014   Alan Boodman   reminder: timed draft begins tomorrow
29894 Feb 16, 2014   Tom Edwards   Re: [SmileyList] cuts/claims reminder
29895 Feb 16, 2014   Alan Boodman   Royals are up
29896 Feb 16, 2014   James Pardee   KC Royals select Polonia
29897 Feb 16, 2014   Alan Boodman   2 teams pick; Twins are up
29898 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   draft officially begins; Marlins are on the clock
29899 Feb 17, 2014   Thomas Treece   Florida selects
29900 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Mets are on the clock
29901 Feb 17, 2014   Jonathan Fellows   Re: [SmileyList] Mets are on the clock
29902 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Orioles pick; Cardinals are on the clock
29903 Feb 17, 2014   Michael Rescigno   Re: [SmileyList] Cards select
29904 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Tigers are on the clock
29905 Feb 17, 2014   Mike Mashanic   Tigers select
29906 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Dodgers are on the clock
29907 Feb 17, 2014   Billy Vanson   Dodgers select
29908 Feb 17, 2014   Billy Vanson   Mr Willie Banks
29909 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Pirates are on the clock
29910 Feb 17, 2014   James Pardee   Re: [SmileyList] Mr Willie Banks
29911 Feb 17, 2014   Mike Mashanic   Pirates select
29912 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Rangers are on the clock
29913 Feb 17, 2014   Michael Rescigno   Re: [SmileyList] Rangers select
29914 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Blue Jays pick; Yankees are on the clock
29915 Feb 17, 2014   Robert Rescigno   RE: [SmileyList] Yankees select
29916 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Blue Jays pick; A's are on the clock
29917 Feb 17, 2014   James Pardee   Has anyone loaded the new 2014 yet? I am gonna need a little help. Jim P
29918 Feb 17, 2014   Andrew Kennedy   Re: [SmileyList] A's select Bill Kreuger
29919 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Tigers are on the clock
29920 Feb 17, 2014   Mike Mashanic   Tigers select
29921 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Braves are on the clock
29922 Feb 17, 2014   Rick Field   Re: [SmileyList] Braves are on the clock
29923 Feb 17, 2014   Alan Boodman   Dodgers are on the clock
29924 Feb 17, 2014   Billy Vanson   Dodgers select
29925 Feb 17, 2014   Thomas Treece   Marlins select
29926 Feb 17, 2014   Andrew Kennedy   Re: [SmileyList] A's select Shawn Boskie-Cubs up
29927 Feb 18, 2014   Alan Boodman   Cubs are on the clock
29928 Feb 18, 2014   Alan Boodman   files updated
29929 Feb 18, 2014   Alan Boodman   Cubs are skipped; Brewers are on the clock
29930 Feb 18, 2014   Tom Edwards   Chicago Cubs catch up Pick
29931 Feb 18, 2014   Mark Simons   Brewers pick
29932 Feb 18, 2014   Alan Boodman   Royals are on the clock
29933 Feb 18, 2014   James Pardee   KC Royals select Leius
29934 Feb 18, 2014   Alan Boodman   Cubs are on the clock
29935 Feb 18, 2014   Tom Edwards   Re: [SmileyList] Cubs are on the clock
29936 Feb 18, 2014   Alan Boodman   Reds pick; Pirates are on the clock
29937 Feb 18, 2014   Mike Mashanic   Pirates select
29938 Feb 18, 2014   Alan Boodman   3 teams pick; Rockies are on the clock
29939 Feb 18, 2014   Billy Vanson   [No subject]
29940 Feb 18, 2014   Herb Wilson   Rockies choose
29941 Feb 18, 2014   Alan Boodman   Cardinals are on the clock
29942 Feb 19, 2014   Michael Rescigno   Re: [SmileyList] Cardinals select
29943 Feb 19, 2014   Thomas Treece   Marlins select
29944 Feb 19, 2014   Billy Vanson   RE: [SmileyList] Marlins select
29945 Feb 19, 2014   Alan Boodman   Dodgers are on the clock
29946 Feb 19, 2014   Billy Vanson   Dodgers pick
29947 Feb 19, 2014   Alan Boodman   Pirates are on the clock
29948 Feb 19, 2014   Mike Mashanic   Re: [SmileyList] Pirates select
29949 Feb 19, 2014   Robert Rescigno   RE: [SmileyList] Rangers select
29950 Feb 19, 2014   Alan Boodman   Blue Jays pick; Yankees are on the clock
29951 Feb 19, 2014   Robert Rescigno   RE: [SmileyList] Yankees pick
29952 Feb 19, 2014   Alan Boodman   Reds pick; Yankees are back on the clock
29953 Feb 19, 2014   Robert Rescigno   RE: [SmileyList] Yankees select Giants up
29954 Feb 19, 2014   Alan Boodman   Giants are on the clock
29955 Feb 19, 2014   Patrick Carr   Re: [SmileyList] Giants are on the clock
29956 Feb 19, 2014   Alan Boodman   Braves are on the clock
29957 Feb 19, 2014   Rick Field   Re: [SmileyList] Braves are on the clock
29958 Feb 19, 2014   Alan Boodman   Dodgers are on the clock
29959 Feb 19, 2014   Billy Vanson   Dodgers selection
29960 Feb 19, 2014   Alan Boodman   Re: [SmileyList] Dodgers selection
29961 Feb 19, 2014   Billy Vanson   Dodgers repick


Previous message                 Next message

Message #: 29861
Message from: Steve Bivens
Sent: Feb 13, 2014
Subject: If you care...Robert Lee Johnson

Thank you to those who responded to my initial inquiry regarding Robert Lee Johnson’s outfield arm rating in Strat.

 

Jason of the HRFL pointed out that this may be a “Chevy” season versus a “Cadillac” season Strat issue.

(For those not in the know, a Cadillac season represents a season in which Strat took the time to do their minute calculations to provide accurate righty/lefty splits among other things.  A Chevy season represents the less minute calculations to produce a more generic representation of the righty/lefty splits).

 

Here is a breakdown of Bob Johnson by season for his assist totals (keeping in mind that this stat is not the end-all of an arm rating discussion),  Strat arm rating and season version (Chevy versus Cadillac):

 

Season             Assists             Arm Rating        Season Version

1933                 16                     +5                    Chevy

1934                 17                     -3                     Cadillac

1935                 13                     +5                    Chevy

1936                 13                     +5                    Chevy

1937                 14                     +5                    Chevy

1938                 21                     -2                     Cadillac

1939                 15                     +5                    Chevy

1940                 15                     +5                    Chevy

1941                 17                     -1                     Cadillac

1942                 18                     +5                    Chevy

1943                 11                     +5                    Chevy

1944                 23!!!                  +5                    Chevy

1945                 16                     +5                    Chevy

 

The pattern would appear to be obvious.  In the three seasons Strat actually did their homework Bob Johnson rated a better than average arm.  So the question is: what is broken in the Chevy formula that is creating this +5 arm? 

To put the +5 arm in perspective: Carlton Fisk in 1979 hurt is arm (shoulder?) and in only 293 innings at CATCHER he threw out only 5 of 29 stolen base attempts and Strat rated his catcher arm at +5 (This seems excessive given that this equals just a bit more than 1 stolen base per nine innings caught, I don’t have the time or knowledge to discuss this intelligently).  That same year Fisk played two-thirds of an inning in left field and received a +4 arm for his trouble.  Bob Johnson plays the same left field and is worse than an injured Fisk???  Yikes!  I suspect even Miley Cyrus is worthy of a +5 or +6 arm if you put her in left at Fenway.

 

Bob Johnson passed away in 1982 so I suppose there is no need for a lawsuit against Strat for slandering his throwing arm.

 

Thanks for listening.     

 

Steve Bivens                  

General Manager   

ALSCO

Tacoma/Seattle

This email message and any attachments are for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential and privileged information.  Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited.  If your are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email immediately and destroy all copies of the original message.  Thank you.

 

Quick Index: Teams | Leagues | Managers | Postseason