|
|
| 104 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Draft Order Ideas |
| 105 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Re: Deeper Draft? Fact or Fiction? |
| 106 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Barry Davis |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: Deeper Draft? Fact or Fiction? |
| 107 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
BTW |
| 108 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
the team draft continues (eventually) |
| 109 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Gary Dewing |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: Where's RESCIGNO? |
| 110 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Serpentine Dratt? |
| 111 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Bivens |
RE: [PreSmiley] Serpentine Dratt? |
| 112 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Re: Serpentine Dratt? |
| 113 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Bivens |
RE: [PreSmiley] Re: Serpentine Dratt? |
| 114 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Re: Serpentine Dratt? |
| 115 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Bivens |
RE: [PreSmiley] Re: Serpentine Dratt? |
| 116 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Re: Serpentine Dratt? |
| 117 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Bivens |
RE: [PreSmiley] Re: Serpentine Dratt? |
| 118 |
Sep 7, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
test |
| 119 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
team draft continues.... now |
| 120 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Jonathan Fellows |
Jon Fellows picks the Chicago White Sox |
| 121 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] Jon Fellows picks the Chicago White Sox |
| 122 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Gary Dewing |
Re: [PreSmiley] Jon Fellows picks the Chicago White Sox |
| 123 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Tom Austad is now up |
| 124 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
PreSmiley@yahoogroups.com |
New poll for PreSmiley |
| 125 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Alan, please check your e-mail |
| 126 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
relievers & HAL |
| 127 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Jonathan Fellows |
Re: New poll for PreSmiley |
| 128 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] Alan, please check your e-mail |
| 129 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: New poll for PreSmiley |
| 130 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Thomas Austad |
Re: Tom Austad is now up |
| 131 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
SteveD takes DETROIT |
| 132 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Thomas Austad |
Re: [PreSmiley] SteveD takes DETROIT |
| 133 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Here's the complete list |
| 134 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
web page updated |
| 135 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Jonathan Fellows |
Re: web page updated |
| 136 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: web page updated |
| 137 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Rick Ramacier |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: Tom Austad is now up |
| 138 |
Sep 8, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Cubs fringe cuts |
| 139 |
Sep 9, 2003 |
Gary Dewing |
Re: [PreSmiley] Cubs fringe cuts - Orioles |
| 140 |
Sep 9, 2003 |
Larry Cupp |
Redleg cuts. |
| 141 |
Sep 9, 2003 |
Michael Tomeo |
RE: [PreSmiley] A's cuts |
| 142 |
Sep 9, 2003 |
Rick Ramacier |
Re: [PreSmiley] Twins fringe cuts |
| 143 |
Sep 9, 2003 |
Barry Davis |
Atlanta Fringe Players |
| 144 |
Sep 10, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Can we decide draft tie-breakers now? |
| 145 |
Sep 10, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] Can we decide draft tie-breakers now? |
| 146 |
Sep 11, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
1967 files have been updated |
| 147 |
Sep 11, 2003 |
Jonathan Fellows |
Re: 1967 files have been updated |
| 148 |
Sep 11, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: 1967 files have been updated |
| 149 |
Sep 11, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
another scheduling issue |
| 150 |
Sep 11, 2003 |
Jonathan Fellows |
White Sox cuts |
| 151 |
Sep 11, 2003 |
Thomas Austad |
Draft |
| 152 |
Sep 11, 2003 |
Gary Dewing |
Re: [PreSmiley] Draft |
| 153 |
Sep 11, 2003 |
Dennis Van Langen |
Pirates cuts |
| 154 |
Sep 12, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
DETROIT cuts |
| 155 |
Sep 12, 2003 |
Larry Cupp |
No cuts |
| 156 |
Sep 12, 2003 |
Darren Dawson |
SF fringe cuts |
| 157 |
Sep 13, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] No cuts |
| 158 |
Sep 13, 2003 |
Larry Cupp |
Re: [PreSmiley] No cuts |
| 159 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Michael Rescigno |
Cardinals Cuts |
| 160 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
1967 fringe cuts |
| 161 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
votes are still open |
| 162 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Jonathan Fellows |
Questions regarding two-carded players |
| 163 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Re: Questions regarding two-carded players |
| 164 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
If I were the NY Mets GM/owner... |
| 165 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Christopher Colucci |
Mets Pick |
| 166 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Re: Mets Pick |
| 167 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Dennis Van Langen |
draft order list |
| 168 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Re: draft order list |
| 169 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
draft order ties in subsequent rounds |
| 170 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
computer manager lineup question |
| 171 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] draft order ties in subsequent rounds |
| 172 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] computer manager lineup question |
| 173 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] Questions regarding two-carded players |
| 174 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Larry Cupp |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: Mets Pick |
| 175 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Re: Mets Pick |
| 176 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Larry Cupp |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: Mets Pick |
| 177 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Re: Mets Pick |
| 178 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Larry Cupp |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: Mets Pick |
| 179 |
Sep 14, 2003 |
Steve Bivens |
Washington Senator Fringe cuts |
| 180 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Michael Tomeo |
Kansas City picks.... |
| 181 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Where's Billy Vanson????? |
| 182 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Billy Vanson |
Re: [PreSmiley] Where's Billy Vanson????? |
| 183 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
1967 files updated |
| 184 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
draft page is up |
| 185 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: NY Yankees selection |
| 186 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Billy Vanson |
NY Yankees selection |
| 187 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Where's Dave Jackson???? |
| 188 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Larry Cupp |
Re: [PreSmiley] draft page is up |
| 189 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] draft page is up |
| 190 |
Sep 15, 2003 |
Gary Dewing |
Re: [PreSmiley] Where's Dave Jackson???? |
| 191 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Dave Jackson |
RE: [PreSmiley] Where's Dave Jackson???? |
| 192 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Dave Jackson |
RE: [PreSmiley] Where's Dave Jackson???? |
| 193 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Steve Dewing |
Re: Where's Dave Jackson???? |
| 194 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
1967 draft begins; Orioles are on the clock |
| 195 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Gary Dewing |
Re: [PreSmiley] 1967 draft begins; Orioles are on the clock |
| 196 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Pirates are on the clock |
| 197 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Larry Cupp |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: Where's Dave Jackson???? |
| 198 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] Re: Where's Dave Jackson???? |
| 199 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Dennis Van Langen |
Buccos pick |
| 200 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Larry Cupp |
Phils pick, "Lets roll" |
| 201 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Re: [PreSmiley] Buccos pick |
| 202 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
Cubs pick; White Sox are on the clock |
| 203 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Alan Boodman |
To Dennis: e-mail issues |
| 204 |
Sep 16, 2003 |
Dave Jackson |
Re: Where's Dave Jackson???? |
|
|
Previous message
Next message
Message #: 104
Message from: Steve Dewing
Sent: Sep 7, 2003
Subject: Draft Order Ideas
With some concerns being noted by some have-nots (those NOT owning
NYA and LAN)I thought it might be a good idea to throw out some ideas
on the order of future drafts so that we can alleviate any concerns
about parity, purity, tanking, and cheating.
BEFORE I START I WOULD LIKE TO STATE THAT SERIOUS CONSIDERATION
SHOULD BE GIVEN TO USING THE REAL-LIFE RECORDS OF OUR TEAMS AS THE
BASIS IN DETERMING DRAFT ORDER. This would completely eliminate any
incentive to "tank". As with any system there will always be
inequities but in general the teams with HOF rookies on the way are
the better won/loss teams. This would address concerns of managers of
the have-nots who would continually face an uphill battle to keep up.
PARITY - we all want to have some chance of competing
PURITY - how close can we maintain a "flavor" of the real-life teams
without seriously effecting PARITY
TANKING - nobody wants this
CHEATING - NOBODY wants this. Anybody who whould cheat (for any
reason) is a mental case. This is a GAME and only a game. I'm only
mentioning this because in certain draft schemes it is a factor.
I'll lay out some options and their advantages/disadvantages.
STRAIGHT W/L - This traditional method is too flawed for
consideration, serious incentive to TANK.
STRAIGHT LOTTERY (each team getting one chance)- status quo is
maintained, no tanking, and no attempt at parity.Also, probably no
one would trade a number one pick because it's value would vary so
widely.
Each team has a 6.2% of getting the top pick
WEIGHTED LOTTERY (the best w/l getting 1 chance, the 2nd best getting
2 chances, and so on.) We still don't know for sure who gets what
pick, there is a minor incentive to tank, and still no incentive to
cheat.
The worst team has an 11.8% chance of getting the #1 pick
The worst three teams have a 33.1% chance of getting #1
The best three teams have a 4.4% chance of getting #1 pick
The best team has a 0.7% chance of getting the #1 pick
WEIGHTED LOTTERY ALTERNATE (the best w/l has 5 chances, the 2nd best
has 6 chances, and so on.) This of course is similar to the above but
the numbers change slightly.
The worst team has a 10% chance of getting #1
The worst three teams have a 28.5% chance of getting #1
The three best teams have a 9.0% chance of getting #1
The best teams has a 2.5% chance of getting #1
The last option I believe achieves the proper balancing of attempting
PARITY and limiting the incentive to TANK.
There you go.
SteveD |
